QA (public) » openQA Project (public)

Motivation¶

Considering #69979#note-6 and subsequent comments people want to avoid restarting the directly chained parent as much as possible and considering that this is usually a long running job it also makes sense.

Acceptance criteria¶

• AC1: Directly chained parents are not restarted if the resulting worker instance would be the same and there was no job from any other cluster running on the worker instance since the original parent ran
• AC2: A directly chained parent is still restarted if the worker ran a job from a different cluster in the meantime

Suggestions¶

This ticket is far from workable. I'm just creating it do save and share an implementation idea I've just had.

1. Actually, restart the directly chained parent. If the parent has already been restarted, just the clone of the parent. (Yes, so far it sounds not like an improvement.)
2. When assigning the directly chained job cluster to a worker, prefer the previously used worker. We already track cloning history and which job has been executed on which worker so that part shouldn't be hard.
3. When sending the job to the worker:
   1. Send the original job IDs from the old directly chained cluster to the worker as well.
   2. Send a list of job IDs we would actually like to skip to the worker. That list would contain the IDs of directly chained parents.
4. The worker checks whether it ran no other jobs then the jobs from 3.1. If it ran other jobs it will just execute all jobs as usual. If it did not run other jobs it will skip jobs from 3.2 and effectively not run the restarted parent jobs again.

This way we would not change a lot in openQA and I guess we would still achieve what the users are after. We would restart the parent "just in case" we really need to re-run it and otherwise just skip the restarted job. It would even work when a worker is working for different web UIs. What do you think? Did I forget something?

Workaround¶

• As an alternative to START_DIRECTLY_AFTER_TEST one can define a specific "machine" with a specific worker class that is only fulfilled by a single, unique worker instance. This can help to optimize test runtime