QA » openQA Project

action #57143

Updated by mkittler over 4 years ago

In legacy Job Group Editor you were not able to add a second combination of the same test suite + arch + flavor + version. It was also not possible if the job group was different. version .  
 In this case you've got an SQL error (see the related ticket). 

 In the YAML Job Group editor you can have the same 'test suite + arch + flavor + version' combination twice in different job groups. E.g. on OSD we currently have: 

 ``` 
 defaults: 
   x86_64: 
     machine: 64bit 
     priority: 50 
 products: 
   sle-15-SP2-Installer-DVD-x86_64: 
     distri: sle 
     flavor: Installer-DVD 
     version: 15-SP2 
 scenarios: 
   x86_64: 
     sle-15-SP2-Installer-DVD-x86_64: 
     - wicked_basic_sut 
     - wicked_advanced_ref 
     - wicked_advanced_sut 
     - wicked_startandstop_sut 
     - wicked_startandstop_ref 
     - wicked_basic_ref 
 ``` 

 and 

 ``` 
 defaults: 
   aarch64: 
     machine: aarch64 
     priority: 50 
   x86_64: 
     machine: 64bit 
     priority: 50 
 products: 
   sle-15-SP2-Installer-DVD-aarch64: &products 
     distri: sle 
     flavor: Installer-DVD 
     version: 15-SP2 
   sle-15-SP2-Installer-DVD-x86_64: 
     *products 
 scenarios: 
   aarch64: 
     sle-15-SP2-Installer-DVD-aarch64: &tests 
     - wicked_basic_sut: &general_settings 
         settings: 
           DESKTOP: textmode 
           EXTRATEST: wicked 
           KEEP_GRUB_TIMEOUT: '1' 
           VIDEOMODE: text 
           WICKED_TCPDUMP: '1' 
           VIRTIO_CONSOLE_NUM: '2' 
     - wicked_advanced_ref: 
         *general_settings 
     - wicked_advanced_sut: 
         *general_settings 
     - wicked_startandstop_sut: 
         *general_settings 
     - wicked_startandstop_ref: 
         *general_settings 
     - wicked_basic_ref: 
         *general_settings 
     - wicked_aggregate_sut: 
         *general_settings 
     - wicked_aggregate_ref: 
         *general_settings 
     - create_hdd_autoyast_wicked: 
         settings: 
           AUTOYAST: autoyast_sle15/autoyast_wicked_%ARCH%.xml 
         priority: 45 
   x86_64: 
     sle-15-SP2-Installer-DVD-x86_64: 
       *tests 
 ``` 

 in the job groups 117 (SLE 15 Development -> Network) and 262 (SLE 15 -> Network). 

 This leads to the job being scheduled twice when posting a new ISO. Considering that the job templates actually exist twice this is expected behavior. The question is whether we want to allow the same 'test suite + arch + flavor + version' combination in different job groups. 

 (Note that the ticket from @asmorodskyi implies that the new editor should check this as the old editor did. I personally would leave this open for discussion.)

Back